That is very true! I read a study which showed some gas engine cars to be just as quiet and even quieter than PHEV/EVs.
Did this end up working with the 2 resistors? Wanting to do it on my '18 clarity
How is any engine noise quieter than no engine noise?
Robert S. Wall Emerson of Western Michigan University has argued that several high-end gasoline-powered luxury cars are already quieter than hybrids, and according to his most recent studies, hybrid SUVs were noisier than many internal-combustion vehicles. He concludes that pedestrian safety is not a hybrid issue but rather "a quiet car issue."
Lol, you’re all over the place. Hybrids, Hybrid SUV, according to someone or another. There is NO engine that can be quieter than not using an engine. Regardless of what you read.
https://www.nhtsa.gov/sites/nhtsa.g...irements_for_hybrid_and_electric_vehicles.pdfIt probably should be a standard EPA-style test -- at a few select speeds in a particular controlled environment, a vehicle must emit X db naturally or artificially to pass. I know it's more complicated than that though (AVAS has specific frequency requirements as I understand it)
To do this I took the speaker cover off:
![]()
and found the speaker to be a simple paper cone attached to a voice coil. I then packed it full of insulation:
It’s only been 2 months, but have the mice has sufficient time to move the insulation from the speaker to the cabin air filter?
You are the absolute GOAT! Been searching for a solution but only ran into people arguing about the ethics of this. I came from a GM EV where it was one fuse pull away from disabling the useless pedestrian noise. IMO it is more of a distraction than it is help, I've had the car only a week and I get nothing but people stopping and staring at me when I'm driving by. When it threw the code, was it persistent or were you able to exit from that screen? Also would it let you drive with that code on?Yes, that is essentially plan C. I took out the speaker again and pulled to boot off to confirm that it was just a speaker.
View attachment 11477
Then I measured the resistance across the speaker and found it to be about 3.75ohms. I don't have an LCR meter so no idea about the inductance. I didnt' have any 3.75ohm resistors so I put a 2 and a 1.5ohm together for about 3.8ohms.
View attachment 11478
I then stuck it in the connector, turned the car back on, then drove up and down the driveway a bit. The warning was gone and didn't pop back up after I left it in for about 10min!
View attachment 11479
With that I put some electronical tape on the connector to hold the resistors in, put the boot back on it, and we'll see how long it lasts.
View attachment 11480
Can the speaker be switched farther upstream where the wiring is more accessible?
If I could get to the same wires from the top side in the engine compartment, it would be simpler.
Honda decided the Canadians abused this privilege the Americans didn't have and removed the pedestrian kill-switch when they updated the Clarity PHEV. Anyway, the switch was inconvenient; it had to be activated every time the car was turned on.The Canadian Clarity models have a switch to disable AVAS, to the left of the steering wheel. It defaults to ON mode when the car is turned on, and you can press the switch to toggle the AVAS on and off.
Even more reason to disable it.Honda decided the Canadians abused this privilege the Americans didn't have and removed the pedestrian kill-switch when they updated the Clarity PHEV. Anyway, the switch was inconvenient; it had to be activated every time the car was turned on.
Honda got even meaner when they updated the Clarity PHEV: in my 2018 Clarity the pedestrian-protection sound turns off when the car is stopped, but after the update the sound is louder and I believe it remains sounding as long as the car is "On."