Android Auto Support

  • Thread starter Thread starter NextEv
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 13
  • Views Views 2K
It is well known that android, google and google auto embraces the ‘minimum viable product’ concept which has pushed a lot of bad and dangerous code through. Version and release control is seriously lacking. App quality control is none existent. It saves big bucks for the developer because it doesn’t go through with the proper level of testing or vetting. Puts a lot of burden off onto an integrator concerned about quality and eventually the customer. Plenty of bugs but more serious is opportunity for privacy invasion and hacking. The typical target for android is cheap, quick to market and because its cheap customers don't mind. Nothing wrong with that, but it gives some pause. I'm guessing it doesn't meet Mini quality standards, or they haven't completed their quality checks and quality seems to be important to their target market. Once they start selling less than capacity, the bean counters may put more pressure.
 
ColdCase said:
It is well known that android, google and google auto embraces the ‘minimum viable product’ concept which has pushed a lot of bad and dangerous code through. Version and release control is seriously lacking. App quality control is none existent. It saves big bucks for the developer because it doesn’t go through with the proper level of testing or vetting. Puts a lot of burden off onto an integrator concerned about quality and eventually the customer. Plenty of bugs but more serious is opportunity for privacy invasion and hacking. The typical target for android is cheap, quick to market and because its cheap customers don't mind. Nothing wrong with that, but it gives some pause. I'm guessing it doesn't meet Mini quality standards, or they haven't completed their quality checks and quality seems to be important to their target market. Once they start selling less than capacity, the bean counters may put more pressure.
Click to expand...

But BMW supports Android Auto and Mini is owned by them.
 
ColdCase said:
It is well known that android, google and google auto embraces the ‘minimum viable product’ concept which has pushed a lot of bad and dangerous code through. Version and release control is seriously lacking. App quality control is none existent. It saves big bucks for the developer because it doesn’t go through with the proper level of testing or vetting. Puts a lot of burden off onto an integrator concerned about quality and eventually the customer. Plenty of bugs but more serious is opportunity for privacy invasion and hacking. The typical target for android is cheap, quick to market and because its cheap customers don't mind. Nothing wrong with that, but it gives some pause. I'm guessing it doesn't meet Mini quality standards, or they haven't completed their quality checks and quality seems to be important to their target market. Once they start selling less than capacity, the bean counters may put more pressure.
Click to expand...

I think that may be a bit harsh. Maybe it was true 10 years ago but I haven't had any issues with android auto on my wife's Subaru or really any of my last couple Android phones.

And based on many posts on this forum about connection issues, Apple car play isn't exactly bug free either...

If BMW put more effort into their built in Nav and voice control I wouldn't mind the lack of Android Auto but out of the dozens of times I've used the MINI system, it has gone smoothly exactly 0 times. I don't even try anymore and just use Google maps on my phone.
For example:
  • Voice command: "navigate to xxx" MINI: ok, calling contact xxx
  • Voice command: : navigate to Starbucks" MINI: ok, navigating to the Starbucks in another city instead of the one 3mi away
  • Repeatedly trying to navigate me through closed or non-existent roads (while Google maps knew the correct route)
 
One can still use either the standalone Android Auto maps app (soon to go away, per Google) OR just run Google Maps standalone app on your Android phone using a phone mount somewhere in the car. Here is a link to one that @F14Scott has recommended and that I now use too -- from Amazon, and not cheap, but really great. Thanks again, @F14Scott!

Screenshot_20210625-155642_Amazon Shopping.webp


https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07QT9H...abc_Q3J6ZJPJSYPYCC6NYA7T?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1
 
Texas22Step said:
One can still use either the standalone Android Auto maps app (soon to go away, per Google) OR just run Google Maps standalone app on your Android phone using a phone mount somewhere in the car.
Click to expand...

The waste of the beautiful screen and domain controller hardware, coupled with the safety compromise of phone placement options are disappointing.
 
I posted on another thread about this but I believe it's a hardware issue. Mini uses the idrive 6 system which was only apple play compatible (and the same as BMWs from 2019 and older) and new BMW's from 2020 onwards use idrive 7 which can use android auto. Mini didn't bother to put idrive 7 in the Mini SE probably because they will just implement in the SE 2024 model.
 
In case others want to try this: AAI Drive is an open source app built to allow certain Android apps (not google maps, but many popular listening apps, calendar, phone, etc.) to connect with the Mini. You can grab it from the Google play app store. I don't have my Mini yet to test, but I plan to.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top