It sounds like you have a strong preference for US vehicles and have had a positive experience with Ford cars. Given your desire for a hybrid or EV with good fuel economy for your short trips, considering a used Fusion or MKZ is a logical choice. These models have been known for their efficiency.
If you'd like to explore other options within your criteria, you might also consider looking at used Chevrolet Volt or Chevrolet Malibu hybrid models. They offer hybrid technology and are known for their fuel efficiency. Additionally, you might keep an eye out for used Toyota Camry hybrids or Prius models if you're open to non-US brands, as they have a reputation for being reliable and fuel-efficient.