Squeaky sound when turning left?

Discussion in 'Cooper SE' started by quietlyspinach, Aug 15, 2021.

To remove this ad click here.

  1. quietlyspinach

    quietlyspinach Active Member

    Has anyone noticed a rhythmic squeaking noise that happens only when turning left in the car, but not always?

    I haven't been able to reproduce the sound on demand; it only happens when I am doing a 90 degree turn to the left, usually at an intersection. It sounds like stuck brake calipers, but it seems to happen regardless of whether I touch the brake pedal at all, and happens even when I am making a left turn without stopping.

    But it doesn't happen all the time; maybe one out of every 10 turns. I'm at a loss as to how to reproduce this for my dealer.
     
    RunOnE likes this.
  2. To remove this ad click here.

  3. Carsten Haase

    Carsten Haase Well-Known Member

    This just happened to me today in the same situation as you described (but when turning right). It happened around two 90deg corners in a row at ~10-15mph without stopping and without hitting the brakes. Definitely was rhythmic and seemed to be timed with one rotation of the tire.

    I did notice that it went away if I turned slightly less sharp and came back if I turned more. This could either be steering angle or turning g-force.

    It did sound like brakes squeaking so maybe it's the pad shifting enough to just graze the rotor? I plan on looking under the car a bit when I get home from work.
     
  4. ColdCase

    ColdCase Active Member

    Also check wheel lug tightness.
     
    Carsten Haase likes this.
  5. Carsten Haase

    Carsten Haase Well-Known Member

    Good call! All four wheels were way under the 101 ft-lb spec (started to move around 60 ft-lb). Shame on me for assuming the dealer would have checked that...

    Not sure if that was actually the cause of the squeak since it was all four wheels but it was definitely a problem
     
  6. Luis Abreu

    Luis Abreu Member

    Maybe some dust on the disks? I've noticed that sound also and it disappeared after washing the car... And then it returns again a few days after the wash...
     
  7. To remove this ad click here.

  8. quietlyspinach

    quietlyspinach Active Member

    I decided to check my wheels and all of them were way under 101 ft-lb as well! I think they were lower than 70.
    I torqued them up to 90 since frankly I'm a bit older now and it's a bit trickier for me to get it up above that comfortably. Hopefully with some test drives I will find out if that solves the issue, but either way, that is a bit worrisome just how much looser the wheels were!

    Is there a reason they could all get so loose at once? Or was it sent from the factory this way and the dealer never bothered to check them?
     
    polyphonic likes this.
  9. F14Scott

    F14Scott Well-Known Member

    They're probably factory torqued while the car is in the air, but being set down on the wheels and then driving can shift wheels that weren't stressed and/or sitting perfectly flush. To do it right, torque once in the air, once on the ground, and once again after 500 miles. I've never seen lugs self-loosen after that routine.

    If the inevitably advancing years make pulling the wrench tough, I highly recommend throwing a pipe on your wrench to give yourself some mechanical advantage, rather than under torquing the lugs.
     
    GvilleGuy likes this.
  10. quietlyspinach

    quietlyspinach Active Member

    Well, after tightening the lug nuts on all wheels, the sound has not gone away. :( Still haven't determine what causes it, and it still happens at the same rate, which is not frequently enough for me to bring it in to the dealer. Hopefully it's nothing serious!
     
  11. polyphonic

    polyphonic Well-Known Member

    Any chance you can capture a video of the sound? I wonder if it would be louder from outside the car? Bimmercode can silence the pedestrian sound to make it even more audible.
     
  12. To remove this ad click here.

  13. quietlyspinach

    quietlyspinach Active Member

    I will see if my dashcam audio captures it; it might be tricky because I definitely feel like it's coming from outside the car, but I haven't had my windows down a lot lately because of the heat!
     
  14. Carsten Haase

    Carsten Haase Well-Known Member

    I did notice the other day that it is much louder with the rear seats down so I'm pretty sure it's coming from the rear. There's not a whole lot going on in the rear of a FWD car that could make squeaking timed with tire rotation so my guess is still the brakes (maybe something to do with the parking brake?)
     
  15. RunOnE

    RunOnE Member

    It's coming from the rear. This is getting worse on my car now. It happens mostly at low speed and turning left.
     
  16. vader

    vader Well-Known Member

    When the car was new(ish), I got a similar "sound" - it turned out to be brake rotor rust. We rarely if ever use the brakes, and they would get surface rust. When the car is new and the pads are full width (ie new), they could scrape. Turning corners puts different stresses on the wheel, and could either start or stop the sound. If found that turning regen to low, and using the brakes quite hard once or twice would tidy up the rotor and stop the sound. Now my car is 2 years old and the pads are slightly worn (I've used the brakes a handful of times in 2 years - mainly for emergency stops). I don't have to clean the rust any more. I guess the pads are far enough away, even with the self calibrating function that it doesn't happen any more.
     
    RunOnE likes this.
  17. Rexsio

    Rexsio Well-Known Member

    BMW I 3 brake rotors were always rusty they advise to use them once a while but SE rotors I never noticed they have any rust but I wash my wheels in garden hose as I’m seeing a dust on them pretty often and I can’t hear any noises I do this with all my cars for 50 years to remove a dust off a pads and calipers and as I look for run off of dust is pretty nasty brown stuff on my driveway.
     

Share This Page