Recall HV battery

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rexsio
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 11
  • Views Views 2K
Rexsio

Rexsio

Well-Known Member
12535 units produced for USA market 128 units has issued for recall means all owners have to see Dealer for inspection and BMW don’t know which one is a lemon ? with very conservative approach 12000 units just 5 hr. Inspection x $200 labor /hr which I my be wrong price wise for labor is going to be $ 12,000,000 and if you assume $30000 car on very low end is 400 cars lost to sell .But this is a learning curve for all EV manufacturers and customer have to suffer for all adventures with new technology .Count a time of 12000 owners in monetary loss also .And a question is why I need patch on HV battery which I pay for new good car ?IMG_1630.webp IMG_1629.webp Nobody or BMW or dealer contacted me or any owner of Mini SE.To inspected HV battery that unit have to be removed from undercarriage of a car is very complicated job and my estimates of price I believe are wrong much more !
 
Last edited:
Green Gatsby said:
Go here and search you VIN

https://www.miniusa.com/owners/tools-support/recall.html
Click to expand...
I did a recall is incomplete call your dealer and they have no answers and read my post you will be there for inspection if you not want to drive aLEMON as 12000 owners of Mini SE As I have no issues with SE a car is perfect but why they scare as with fire sudden stop etc ? And if anybody search a VN number what they a telling you about your SE just post a picture for anybody to know what BMW come up to answer those questions I post my as incomplete recall ???????
 
Last edited:
I also checked the MINI recall lookup tool, and it came back basically empty for me as well... Besides saying it's a "High-Voltage Battery Software" recall. However, the letter I received in the mail last week indicates that it's campaign 24V-612.

Here's the full write up on 24V-612. It explains the timeline, root cause and remedy (which is a software update).
 
joshf2k said:
I also checked the MINI recall lookup tool, and it came back basically empty for me as well... Besides saying it's a "High-Voltage Battery Software" recall. However, the letter I received in the mail last week indicates that it's campaign 24V-612.

Here's the full write up on 24V-612. It explains the timeline, root cause and remedy (which is a software update).
Click to expand...
"Identification of Any Warning: The vehicle will display a warning message to the driver"

What is the message? Perhaps, "RUN!"
 
MrSnrub said:
Estimated 5% is nearly 630cars… oh boy this is going to get interesting
Click to expand...
And yet:

"As of August 2024, BMW is aware of approximately 2 customer complaints, concerns, and/or field instances, that relate, or may relate, to the issue identified in this report."

So, either SE owners are just a happy, uncomplaining lot, far less than 630 vehicles* are actually affected, or it's going to take many more years/miles/charging cycles for any problems to really emerge.

*In the US. 5% of the 70-80k sold worldwide would be 3500-4000 cars.

ETA: To help put things in perspective, if you assume that the odds of a thermal event are 1:35000-1:40000, that's roughly equivalent of being killed by a lightening strike or a falling meteorite. A casual bowler apparently has better odds of scoring 300.

https://stacker.com/art-culture/odds-50-random-events-happening-you
 
Last edited:
Car companies are notorious for downplaying customer concerns. An EV fire is also a very, very different thing than an ICEV fire and that should go without saying.
 
polyphonic said:
Car companies are notorious for downplaying customer concerns. An EV fire is also a very, very different thing than an ICEV fire and that should go without saying.
Click to expand...

Do mean in it’s rarity?

Definitely a lot different. ICE fire is much quicker, more explosive, and more likely to kill.

I lose absolutely no sleep over worrying about my SE battery.



Sent from my iPhone using Inside EVs
 
Jim In Tucson said:
I lose absolutely no sleep over worrying about my SE battery.
Click to expand...

Me neither.

Now all those other lithium batteries in the house (snow blower, lawnmower, string trimmer, kids' old hoverboards, old laptops, old tablets, old digital camera, etc.) without any cooling or monitoring/safety systems are another story!

Hmm. Could I wire them all together and have my very own homebuilt Powerwall?
 
My car has thrown so many HV errors while terminating DCFCs, that I've started wondering if I can get bimmercode can hide the damn things so I that don't need to get the dealer to shrug and clear them.

Google 'normalisation of deviance'.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top