Would you buy this car again?

  • Thread starter Thread starter polyphonic
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 38
  • Views Views 6K

Would you buy this car again?

  • No

    Votes: 4 11.8%

  • Yes

    Votes: 27 79.4%

  • Already did

    Votes: 3 8.8%
  • Total voters
    34
polyphonic

polyphonic

Well-Known Member
Just for fun :)

I was thinking about Tesla's overwhelming owner satisfaction scores and how electrification probably improved MINI's numbers. Wouldn't be surprised if MINI is right there with them.
 
I was relatively late to the SE. After a life event allowed me to lower my D/E ratio substantially, I was able to consider buying myself my first new car in 15 years (my wife’s car is fairly new, and a CUV at that, allowing me a more unique choice). I started looking at new vehicles, but really wanted to go BEV — I’ve written previously that Quebec is the ideal place in North America to justify a BEV, with 99.7% of our electricity from renewables. I honestly didn’t know a series-production version of the MINI e existed, as there is ZERO marketing of the brand up here (though I see MINIs everywhere… IYKYK). After getting frustrated last spring while looking for in-stock BEVs to test, and that my choice was set to be limited to the Bolt, or a bunch of CUVs that are more than I need, I Googled “EVs available in Canada” and was shocked to see the series production version of the MINI e had already been available for almost two years. I immediately set out to test drive it, and though I’d experienced Teslas and Kia EVs as well as the 2021 Bolt, I was sold on the SE within the first five minutes. I’m new to the brand, but have been a lifelong small (and usually quirky) car addict.

Would I add another SE? No, we are DINKs and don’t need a third car again, but if we wanted another fun toy car for summer, I’m now keeping my eye open for a good deal on a 2012-13 Roadster S or JCW. Prices for the long-lusted-after S2000 AP2 keep climbing to the point where I won’t ever be able to justify (or afford) one in good shape. The Roadie seems to still be hovering under the radar, with a low-mileage S around $10k and a nice JCW nearby asking $16k.
 
SameGuy said:
Would I add another SE? No, we are DINKs and don’t need a third car again, but if we wanted another fun toy car for summer, I’m now keeping my eye open for a good deal on a 2012-13 Roadster S or JCW. Prices for the long-lusted-after S2000 AP2 keep climbing to the point where I won’t ever be able to justify (or afford) one in good shape. The Roadie seems to still be hovering under the radar, with a low-mileage S around $10k and a nice JCW nearby asking $16k.
Click to expand...

Just for sake of absolute clarity, the question is only if you would repeat the decision if given a do-over, not adding another car.
Consumer Reports famously asks this question in their surveys: “Considering all factors (price, performance, reliability, comfort, enjoyment, etc.), would you get the same vehicle if you had it to do all over again?”
 
I'm surprised at the Tesla owner satisfaction. My wife is trying to make a 3rd appointment to turn off her passenger seat seatbelt warning sign. The first 2 times they had someone come out to our house. Obviously, it didn't work.

We've had it for a year. For Tesla being a tech company, their software is buggy. I couldn't imagine trusting their FSD.
 
probably not without the 7500. but, it is my third car, and i can only drive one at a time.
 
polyphonic said:
Just for sake of absolute clarity, the question is only if you would repeat the decision if given a do-over, not adding another car.
Consumer Reports famously asks this question in their surveys: “Considering all factors (price, performance, reliability, comfort, enjoyment, etc.), would you get the same vehicle if you had it to do all over again?”
Click to expand...
Then yes, 100% yes.
 
Today? Probably. But likely not in a few years.

I’m not impressed by the Aceman future and I kind of want it all - compact, stylish, fun, decent range, and good tech. It’s clearly not that today and I don’t think MINI has it in them (or if they do BMW won’t let it happen.)
 
For the $20k I paid after all of the rebates, absolutely!

My experience has only improved in the last year thanks to Oregon's DCFC expansion and should get even better in the next year based on their published/approved NEVI plan (infrastructure bill)
 
When I'm driving fast down a winding country road, my eyes are nearly bulging out of my head, looking for suicidal deer seeking to destroy my favorite car ever.

upload_2022-9-25_0-38-58.webp


I'll be sad when it becomes impossible to order a new Oxford SE in case I need to replace mine. Before MINI announced the price in 2019, I was prepared to spend $40K after the $7,500 tax credit. What a delight it was to spend so much less for such a great car! I'd pay $40K if I needed a new one--there is no other car like it at any price.
 
Definitely 100% YES. And if I have the money, I will buy also a Resolute Edition, and a Chili Red one and another Black One with a Chili Red roof, and another which I will repaint with a Black Matte finish.
 
insightman said:
When I'm driving fast down a winding country road, my eyes are nearly bulging out of my head, looking for suicidal deer seeking to destroy my favorite car ever.

View attachment 18386

I'll be sad when it becomes impossible to order a new Oxford SE in case I need to replace mine. Before MINI announced the price in 2019, I was prepared to spend $40K after the $7,500 tax credit. What a delight it was to spend so much less for such a great car! I'd pay $40K if I needed a new one--there is no other car like it at any price.
Click to expand...
Just keep SE should be good for next10 years at least without Oxford replacement .bc 10 years later they will be absolute.
 
If the $7500 tax credit, were still available——definitely yes.

Without the credit, I would wait a bit for the crazy used car market to cool off and to look for a deal on a used SE. I keep my cars for a long time, typically 20 years or more (for ICE cars, anyway), so I’m fine not buying the latest technology.
 
polyphonic said:
Just for sake of absolute clarity, the question is only if you would repeat the decision if given a do-over, not adding another car.
Consumer Reports famously asks this question in their surveys: “Considering all factors (price, performance, reliability, comfort, enjoyment, etc.), would you get the same vehicle if you had it to do all over again?”
Click to expand...

So for actual clarity, does it mean a do-over at the price I paid or todays price?
Because if I could go back in time and do it again I would. Today I would not.
 
polyphonic said:
I was assuming the original deal.
Click to expand...
Oh, I was assuming the current tax-creditless deal when I said I'd definitely buy again. Of course, if that's my attitude, it doesn't really matter that I didn't understand you were assuming the cost with the $7,500 tax credit.

I find it interesting that some people who chose the MINI Cooper SE based on price alone were lucky to get such a great car, but after driving this great car they don't like it enough to consider it worth paying more than they did.
 
ghost said:
I'm surprised at the Tesla owner satisfaction. My wife is trying to make a 3rd appointment to turn off her passenger seat seatbelt warning sign. The first 2 times they had someone come out to our house. Obviously, it didn't work.

We've had it for a year. For Tesla being a tech company, their software is buggy. I couldn't imagine trusting their FSD.
Click to expand...

Some of that is 'luxury bias' where people overlook problems because they feel they bought the *best* there is in a category. Teslas have well documented quality issues, but they are generally overlooked and not discussed online for fear of the fanboi brigade coming at you.

Hair in the paint on some Model Ys, early Model 3s with general hardware brackets from Lowe's/Home Depot holding components, misaligned body/trim, etc.

https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1128625_tesla-ranks-last-in-initial-quality-build-issues

My neighbor has a Model 3 bought early this year and no issues he has mentioned. I do think the Model 3 is a bit more mature now and the manufacturing process has been improved.

I now have to go into witness protection from the Tesla brigade.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top