Any insight greatly appreciated.
Who better than
@insightman to answer this question? Actually, unlike
@MichaelC and others on this forum, I'm no expert on wheels.
I chose the Power Spoke wheels because they are unique to the SE and are supposedly the lightest 17" wheels MINI makes. However, their unique design presents some problems. First, MINI had to create a special tool to enable the balancing of the Power Spoke wheels:
I don't know how much this tool costs or what tire shops would do to balance a Power Spoke wheel without it.
A second problem with the Power Spoke wheels is the thin Energetic Yellow stripe around the circumference of the rim. I would be very unhappy to scrape my wheel against a concrete curb and ruin that stripe.
A third problem is that the aerodynamic panels are plastic. It might be very good plastic, but I don't believe it would be as durable as aluminum.
I'll be putting my Power Spoke wheels in storage soon to keep them in pristine condition for special events (assuming there will be events). My wife is resisting my suggestion that we display one in our living room. A slightly used set of 16" Loop Spoke wheels will take the punishment of year-after-year exposure to the hazards of driving on the terrible roads (and greedy curbs) of Ann Arbor.
MINI's various other 17" wheels and their 205-width tires are going to provide better cornering than 16-inchers (most of which are 6.5" wide) with their 195-width tires, but the 16" Loop Spokes will be easier to fit with the winter tires I want (the reputedly quiet Michelin X-Ice winter tires). Next year, I'll work on coming up with a clever psychological ploy to convince my wife we need a 3rd set of wheels. If I pass the psychological challenge, then I'll start looking at used 17" OEM MINI wheels and get new summer tires.