Car running on ice/gas despite full battery

Discussion in 'Clarity' started by ace base, Jul 27, 2018.

To remove this ad click here.

Tags:
  1. insightman

    insightman Well-Known Member Subscriber

    As shown in the graph from the manual that Weave presented above, the detent or "click" is meaningful only in ECON Mode. It's too bad Honda couldn't figure out how (OK, spend the bucks) to adjust the detent position to signal ICE activation for the other two modes, too.
     
  2. To remove this ad click here.

  3. AnthonyW

    AnthonyW Well-Known Member

    See picture below. I usually stop at 340v (340/84=4.047v) on a full charge but on that day it went up to 342. I attributed this to one or all of three reasons. Ambient temp was 96, I might be out of balance as I only fully charge twice a week and/or I took the reading right after charging was completed.

    Never the less the Emergency Response Guide says max voltage is 352. Open circuit voltage is not linear as it relates to SOC but it is most accurate near the top and bottom of charge state. For that reason I believe we are in the 96% range.

    As Wayne said we don’t know what Honda’s secret sauce is. Their mixture of nickel, manganese and cobalt might lend to different capacity and charging parameters. I was going to look around for some of their patents or patent applications, but my 4 year old wanted to wrestle so I never got around to it. :)

    2018-07-16 09.50.22.jpg


    Sent from my iPhone using Inside EVs
     
  4. weave

    weave Active Member

    That there folks is the comment of the week!
     
  5. Alex0913

    Alex0913 Member

    Haha he has his priorities straight! And I truly mean that.
     
    AnthonyW likes this.
  6. ace base

    ace base Member

    OP here, in both their was no switch that I noticed going from blue to while or in between, the card went into while odometer very quickly after start.

    1) Can be explained with my drive starting with a small down hill, and with sports mode and four chevron regen and full battery. The car had to run ICE to expel additional power. This does not happen usually as I drive in normal mode, where regen is pretty low.

    2) Is still problematic, as the ICE ran in low speeds < 30mph for about 1.5 miles, then high speed about 80mph for 6 miles than again at < 25 mph. This happened for around for 11 mins with full battery. I had a pit stop, where I stopped and restarted the car and then it ran in EV in Sports mode. So this baffles me.
     
  7. To remove this ad click here.

  8. weave

    weave Active Member

    Try using normal brakes and not paddles for a bit after starting off. I'm wondering if the battery is full if it's smart enough to just use all friction when braking in that case. That seems to me to make more sense than having the brakes regenerate electricity and then having to run the engine to dump it.
     
  9. Viking79

    Viking79 Well-Known Member

    The Voltage is correct, but that isn't 96% SoC. Again, it is more like 85% as battery SoC is not linear with voltage so you can't just take 4.05/4.2 volts. Look at the charge curves on pages 4 and 5 of this study: http://www.mdpi.com/2313-0105/4/1/11/pdf
    And draw a line from 4.05 volts and you will see it is about 80 to 85% SoC for those two NMC cells.

    Yes, it is sort of linear in that region, but again, not accurate to take 4.05/4.2. If you did a linear model you would have to say 3 or some other non-zero value as the bottom, so you would take (4.05-3)/(4.2-3) which would be 87.5%, but this still doesn't really fit. It is not safe to assume a linear relationship for Li-ion, which is why people model this behavior to get more accurate SoC based on Voltage.

    Here is another chart from battery university that shows 4.05 V corresponds to about 80-85% SoC.
    http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/article/how_to_prolong_lithium_based_batteries

    If Honda charge to 96% we might have longevity problems with the batteries. Charging to 85% puts them right in that sweet range for NMC and it should last 5000 cycles or more. I imagine this battery will last life of the car barring other failures. I know at least one Volt was around 150,000 EV miles (Over 400,000 total miles) and didn't have any real capacity loss or pretty minor.
     
    weave likes this.
  10. You know what? I don't think I have either! That's my new goal tomorrow. Let's see what this baby can do!

    But don't worry. It'll be only once.

    That said...I told my wife to put it into Sport mode when she knows high acceleration is necessary.
     

Share This Page